- male
- 25 Years
- 14/08/2025
I've taken my brother to two doctors and both recommended surgery, but they suggested different procedures. One doctor mentioned arthroscopic MPFL ligament reconstruction with loose body removal, while the other advised left knee arthroscopic osteochondral loose body removal. They found a small bone chip in his knee on the MRI. Do you think surgery is really necessary, and which procedure would be better for his case?
Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors
Both surgeries are valid for loose bodies and instability—arthroscopic MPFL is better if recurrent dislocations are present.
Dr. Dhankecha Suggests...
Consult a Orthopaedician
Answered 14/08/2025
0
0
More Orthopaedics Health Queries
View allI'm worried about my chondromalacia diagnosis from a few years ago. I sometimes didn't stick to the doctor's advice about not jumping, running, or folding my knees, and now Im experiencing knee pain whenever I put stress on them. I recently started karate classes that involve a lot of those activities. Is there anything youd recommend I do to manage the pain and keep my knees in good shape while still attending classes?
As advised by the physician , avoid running,exercises ,folding knees,jogging since you are prone to fractures .
Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors
I'm currently being treated for a lateral femoral condyle fracture and wearing a long knee brace without surgery. Just got my MRI reports. Wondering if there are any specific exercises, suggestions, or special meds that could help speed up recovery? Really want to get back on my feet faster.
Post your xray pic
Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors
I met with an accident a week ago and the first doctor I saw recommended surgery but the second one said it's not needed. Why do doctors have such different opinions about the same injury? It's really confusing and worrying me.
If you receive conflicting opinions from two doctors, consider the following steps: Understand the Opinions: Take time to understand both diagnoses and treatment recommendations. Ask each doctor to explain their reasoning. Gather More Information: Research the conditions and suggested treatments to better understand the medical issues at hand. Ask Questions: Reach out to both doctors with any questions or concerns you have about their opinions. This could clarify their reasoning and help you make an informed decision. Seek a Third Opinion: If you're still uncertain, consider consulting a third doctor. This can provide additional perspectives and help you weigh your options. Consider Specialization: If the opinions differ significantly, it might be useful to consult a specialist related to the specific condition. Evaluate Your Options: After gathering all the information, consider your own health, preferences, and values when making a decision about treatment. Trust Your Instincts: Ultimately, trust your instincts about which opinion resonates more with you, and feel empowered to choose a path that feels right. Follow Up: Regardless of the decision, ensure you have a plan for follow-up care and monitoring. It's important to have open communication with your healthcare providers throughout this process
Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors
Health Articles for you
View all
Disclaimer: Answers on Apollo 247 are not intended to replace your doctor advice. Always seek help of a professional doctor in case of an medical emergency or ailment.