My MRI shows a complete ACL tear and mild joint effusion but the doctor with 25 years of experience says there's no ACL injury just mild cartilage damage and the MRI doesn't match his clinical findings He suggested physiotherapy and a knee brace for 6 months with possible surgery only if needed Should I trust this diagnosis or get a second opinion

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

Dr Kamran Mohammed

General Practitioner

MBBS
FIDM
5+ Yrs

Consult Now

It's understandable to feel concerned when your MRI contradicts your doctor's assessment. While your doctor's experience is valuable, a second opinion is advisable to ensure a comprehensive understanding of your knee injury.

Dr. Kamran Suggests...

Consult a Orthopaedician

Find a Orthopaedician

Answered 14/08/2025

More Orthopaedics Health Queries

View all

I've had knee pain for 10 years and been doing physiotherapy for the past year. My hip joint snaps when climbing stairs with slight pain, but the main issue is IT band pain at the knee. I do stretching and strengthening exercises regularly but don't feel much improvement. Could this condition require surgery or are there other treatment options I should consider?

physiotherapy and painkillers to manage your condition

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

Can grade 1 anterolisthesis at L4-L5 with a disc bulge heal naturally without surgery, or is surgery the only option? Will proper exercises and less strenuous activities help the vertebrae return to their original position, or will it eventually progress to higher grades and require surgery later?

surgery is advised,discectomy is advised.

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

I'm a bit worried about a partial tear in my medial patellofemoral ligament. Is surgery necessary, or is it something that could heal with just rest? What would be the best approach for treatment?

if it is partial tear it can be cured by rest and physiotheraphy. if still pain is persisting and reduced movements then surgery is better option

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

Health Articles for you

View all

Musculoskeletal Disorders

All About Scoliosis: Understanding, Managing, and Living with Curved Spines

Learn everything about scoliosis, including its causes, symptoms, treatment options, and tips for managing and living with a curved spine. Discover effective strategies for scoliosis care and support.

Musculoskeletal Disorders

Bone Strengthening Foods for Women

Understating importance of bone strength and Learning about its nutritional needs, important nutrients and its sources, life style and its clinical implications and complications of inadequate bone nutrition.

Wrist Problems

Guide to Wrist Surgeries Types And Recovery

Explore our comprehensive guide to wrist surgeries. Learn about different types of procedures, what to expect during recovery, and tips for a successful rehabilitation. Get the facts you need to make informed decisions about your wrist health.

Musculoskeletal Disorders

Understanding Clubfoot: Signs, Exercises, Treatment

Learn about clubfoot, its signs, treatment options like the Ponseti method, and essential exercises for recovery. Get expert insights on managing clubfoot effectively.

Back Pain

Guide to Managing Chronic Back Pain

Learn effective strategies to manage chronic back pain, improve mobility, and enhance daily life. Discover treatments, exercises, and lifestyle tips.

Disclaimer: Answers on Apollo 247 are not intended to replace your doctor advice. Always seek help of a professional doctor in case of an medical emergency or ailment.