My MRI shows a complete ACL tear and mild joint effusion but the doctor with 25 years of experience says there's no ACL injury just mild cartilage damage and the MRI doesn't match his clinical findings He suggested physiotherapy and a knee brace for 6 months with possible surgery only if needed Should I trust this diagnosis or get a second opinion

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

Dr Kamran Mohammed

General Practitioner

MBBS
FIDM
5+ Yrs

Consult Now

It's understandable to feel concerned when your MRI contradicts your doctor's assessment. While your doctor's experience is valuable, a second opinion is advisable to ensure a comprehensive understanding of your knee injury.

Dr. Kamran Suggests...

Consult a Orthopaedician

Find a Orthopaedician

Answered 14/08/2025

More Orthopaedics Health Queries

View all

my granny is 70 and her knees hurt a lot is knee replacement an option for her can you suggest some good doctors or hospitals and what would be the best package for both knees

For a 70-year-old experiencing severe knee pain, knee replacement is a viable option, and it's often considered a life-changing procedure to improve mobility and reduce pain. A comprehensive consultation with an orthopedic surgeon specializing in joint replacements is the first step to determine if it's the right choice, and they can guide you on the best package options for both knees.

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

I have a ligament injury in my right knee and got an MRI done is it possible to recover without surgery or would I need to go that route

Small ligament injuries can heal with bracing and rehab; surgery if instability or tear is complete.

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

I have a bony avulsion fracture of my PCL with a bone fragment that's mildly displaced posterosuperiorly and measures around 16x15x10 mm. All my other ligaments are intact. Will this heal with just 4 weeks in a plaster cast or do I need surgery for it?

MRI is advised,ortho opinion

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

Health Articles for you

View all

Osteopetrosis

Understanding Osteoporosis: A Comprehensive Guide to Stronger Bones

Discover a complete guide to osteoporosis—causes, symptoms, diagnosis, treatment, and prevention strategies for stronger, healthier bones.

Back Pain

Guide to Lower Back Pain Due Spinal Arthritis Non Surgical Pain Management Options

Your guide to managing lower back pain from spinal arthritis without surgery. Explore effective options including physical therapy, medication, lifestyle adjustments, and alternative therapies.

Muscle cramp

Charley Horse: Causes, Relief, and How to Prevent It

Discover the causes of charley horses, learn effective techniques for immediate relief, and explore proven strategies to prevent leg cramps.

Musculoskeletal Disorders

Spondylolisthesis: A comprehensive overview

Discover spondylolisthesis, its types, symptoms, causes and risk factors. Get information about diagnosis of spondylolisthesis, treatment options and how to manage life with it.

Musculoskeletal Disorders

Thigh Pain: Top Causes, Symptoms, and When to See a Doctor

Discover the top causes of thigh pain, from muscle strains and nerve compression to arthritis and blood clots. Learn symptoms, red flags, treatments, and when to see a doctor.

Disclaimer: Answers on Apollo 247 are not intended to replace your doctor advice. Always seek help of a professional doctor in case of an medical emergency or ailment.