My MRI shows a complete ACL tear and mild joint effusion but the doctor with 25 years of experience says there's no ACL injury just mild cartilage damage and the MRI doesn't match his clinical findings He suggested physiotherapy and a knee brace for 6 months with possible surgery only if needed Should I trust this diagnosis or get a second opinion

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

Dr Kamran Mohammed

General Practitioner

MBBS
FIDM
5+ Yrs

Consult Now

It's understandable to feel concerned when your MRI contradicts your doctor's assessment. While your doctor's experience is valuable, a second opinion is advisable to ensure a comprehensive understanding of your knee injury.

Dr. Kamran Suggests...

Consult a Orthopaedician

Find a Orthopaedician

Answered 14/08/2025

More Orthopaedics Health Queries

View all

I've had an ACL injury that doesn't seem to be healing properly - my knee still makes popping sounds and hurts when I try to move it. I can't bend my knee all the way or climb stairs without pain. Should I consider surgery for this?

physiotherapy and painkillers to manage your condition

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

I've been having issues with my spine at the L5 level and there's some space there not sure how it happened. Is it possible to recover from this without needing surgery?

Yes, recovery from spine issues at the L5 level, including those involving space or alignment, is often possible without surgery. Conservative treatments like physical therapy, pain management, and lifestyle modifications are frequently the first line of care.

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

My mom is 64 and has osteoporosis with knee pain in both legs. She had an accident 10 years ago and still has a rod in her left thigh that runs from the upper thigh to just above the knee. I'm wondering if the rod needs to be removed before she gets knee replacement surgery. Also, the doctor suggested replacing both knees what are the risks and success rates for someone with her condition?

ortho opinion is advised at apollo hospital.

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

Health Articles for you

View all

Muscle Spasm

How To Reduce Muscle Soreness?

Learn effective ways to reduce muscle soreness, speed up recovery, and stay active without discomfort. Discover simple tips for faster healing and stronger muscles.

Musculoskeletal Disorders

Everything You Need to Know About Ankle Surgery

Learn everything you need to know about ankle surgery, including types of procedures, recovery time, and what to expect. Get expert insights on treatment options for fractures, arthritis, ligament damage, and more.

Musculoskeletal Disorders

Understanding Arm Pain: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options

Explore the causes of arm pain, from injuries to underlying health conditions. Learn about common symptoms and effective treatment options to find relief and improve mobility.

Back Pain

Ways to Prevent Back Pain and Improve Spinal Health

Discover effective strategies to prevent back pain and maintain spinal health, including posture tips, exercises, and lifestyle habits for a stronger, pain-free back.

Spine

Guide to New Help All Spinal Problems Live Better

Discover new, effective help for all spinal problems. This comprehensive guide offers treatments, exercises, and tips to manage pain and live better with back or neck issues

Disclaimer: Answers on Apollo 247 are not intended to replace your doctor advice. Always seek help of a professional doctor in case of an medical emergency or ailment.