My MRI shows a complete ACL tear and mild joint effusion but the doctor with 25 years of experience says there's no ACL injury just mild cartilage damage and the MRI doesn't match his clinical findings He suggested physiotherapy and a knee brace for 6 months with possible surgery only if needed Should I trust this diagnosis or get a second opinion

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

Dr Kamran Mohammed

General Practitioner

MBBS
FIDM
5+ Yrs

Consult Now

It's understandable to feel concerned when your MRI contradicts your doctor's assessment. While your doctor's experience is valuable, a second opinion is advisable to ensure a comprehensive understanding of your knee injury.

Dr. Kamran Suggests...

Consult a Orthopaedician

Find a Orthopaedician

Answered 14/08/2025

More Orthopaedics Health Queries

View all

Last Friday I twisted my leg and it's been hurting a lot since then. There's some swelling too. I'm pretty worried about it. Could you recommend some treatment options or suggest a good doctor I could see for this?

X-ray of the leg AP and oblique viewis advised since swelling is present, and an orthopaedic opinion is advised to the patient.

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

I tore my ACL on July 11 but my lifestyle is pretty normal since I'm just a student do I really need surgery for this or can I manage without it

ACL repair and reconstructive sx is advised.

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

I've been dealing with this annoying lower back pain for the last 23 days. It's strange because it doesn't hurt when I'm walking or sleeping, but it really bothers me when I sit down. Could you recommend any medicine or treatment that might help with this?

it could possibly due to muscle sprain due to any sudden activities use muscle relaxants like zerodol mr and consult your orthopedic for further evaluation and diagnosis

Answered by 1 Apollo Doctors

Health Articles for you

View all

Spondylosis

Your Ultimate Guide to Preventing and Managing Spinal Spondylosis

Discover how to prevent and manage spinal spondylosis with practical tips on posture, exercise, ergonomics, and treatment options for a pain-free, active life.

Musculoskeletal Disorders

Understanding Tennis Elbow: Symptoms, Causes, and Management

Discover the symptoms, causes, and effective management strategies for tennis elbow. Learn how to relieve pain, prevent recurrence, and regain strength in your arm.

Spine Fractures

Guide to Fragile Patient Broken Spine Regains Painless Movement Within 24

Learn how fragile patients can regain painless movement within 24 hours after a spinal fracture. Explore modern pain management, minimally invasive procedures, and rapid recovery strategies.

Knock Knees

Guide to Knock Knees

Understand knock knees (genu valgum), including causes, symptoms, self-checks, treatment options for children and adults, exercises, surgery, and bone health tips.

Musculoskeletal Disorders

Bone Cancer Risk Factors

Understating what is bone cancer and Learning about its types, risk factors and its clinical implications, symptoms and prevention strategy.

Disclaimer: Answers on Apollo 247 are not intended to replace your doctor advice. Always seek help of a professional doctor in case of an medical emergency or ailment.